In Praise of Blood: The Crimes of the Rwandan Patriotic Front
AuthorJudi Rever
PublisherRandom House of Canada
Publication date
March 2018
ISBN978-0-345-81210-0

In Praise of Blood: The Crimes of the Rwandan Patriotic Front is a 2018 non-fiction book by Canadian journalist Judi Rever and published by Random House of Canada; it has also been translated into Dutch and French. The book describes alleged war crimes by the Rwandan Patriotic Front (RPF), Rwanda's ruling political party, during its ascent to power in the 1990s.

Although many of the events described in Rever's book were already known to historians, the book is controversial. Praised for thorough investigation at considerable personal risk to the author, the book was also criticized for sensationalism and relying on unreliable sources. According to historian Gerald Caplan, the book "had an immediate, destabilizing influence on the world of orthodox Rwandan scholarship".[1] Rever argues that, in addition to the Rwandan genocide by Hutus against Tutsis, the war crimes against Hutus by the Tutsi-led RPF should also be labeled "genocide", an opinion that differed from existing historical narratives.[2]

Background

Judi Rever

In Rwanda, the two major ethnic groups are Hutu (85%) and Tutsi (14%).[3] European colonial policies promoted and racialized the higher status of cattle-raising Tutsis over farming Hutus. European policies, including their support for a Tutsi monarchy, increased tension between the two groups. In the 1959 Rwanda Revolution, a Hutu-led movement killed many Rwandan Tutsis and drove hundreds of thousands into exile. [4]

Descendants of Rwandan Tutsis whose families had fled to Uganda gave armed support to a rebellion by Yoweri Museveni. Then in 1990, their Tutsi-led political and military force, Rwandan Patriotic Front (RPF), challenged the Hutu-led government of Rwanda, setting off the Rwandan Civil War.[5]

Judi Rever is a Canadian journalist who has covered African affairs since the refugee crisis of the First Congo War, which she covered for Radio France Internationale.[6][7] A three year stint as correspondent for Agence France Press (AFP) in Ivory Coast followed.[8] Her work has also appeared in Le Monde, Le Monde Diplomatique, The Globe and Mail and elsewhere. She contributed the foreword to Victoire Ingabire Umuhoza's 2017 book Between 4 Walls of the 1930 Prison: Memoirs of Rwandan Prisoner of Conscience.[9] In the book, Rever describes threats against herself and her family, some of which were reported in 2015 news stories documenting threats against Rever and four other Canadian critics of Paul Kagame.[10][11]

Content

Canada has given roughly $550 million to Rwanda since 1994 including $30 million in 2016. Why does it keep sending money to a government that is strongly suspected of murdering two Canadian citizens?
It seemed that the RPF could now commit crimes out in the open and still receive billions of dollars in aid. What were these Western allies supporting? From the point of view of the RPF’s victims, it all seemed to be in praise of blood, an endorsement of mass murder.

—Judi Rever[12]

In Praise of Blood follows the timeline of a Canadian reporter who in 1997 stumbled on a big "story" about the RPF and later pursued it. The book describes events in Rwanda and Zaire (later the DRC) that according to Rever's sources were crimes committed by the RPF during the rise to power of Kagame, now Rwanda's president.[13] The book discusses several periods during which these events took place: the Rwandan civil war including the 1994 Rwandan genocide (1990–1994); the counterinsurgency period in Rwanda (1994–1997); RPF participation in two Congo wars (First and Second); and more recently, deaths of Rwanda dissidents.[14][15] RPF massacres of Hutu civilians described in the book include Byumba, Kibeho, Karambi, Gabiro, Gikongoro.[16]

The book's fifteen chapters follow the sequence of Rever's research, beginning when Rever was a young reporter traveling with humanitarian workers into the Congolese jungle to cover the refugee crisis there, and tracing her later research parallel to events in her life, including her marriage and raising two daughters.[17] Each chapter centers around one event, presented (according to Rever) as a cinematic scene. [18]

Origins of the project

Chapters 1 and 2[19] cover 1997, beginning when Rever accompanied humanitarian aid workers into the jungles of Zaire. After meeting women and children who said they were Hutu refugees being hunted by RPF troops from Rwanda, Rever wonders why western countries did not step in to stop the violence. Based on her research, Rever concludes that western countries were less interested in helping refugees than in keeping the good will of Rwanda's new RPF government—first to get rid of Mobutu and later to exploit the Congo's resources.[20]

In Chapters 3 and 4,[21] Rever decides to spend time away from Rwanda with her husband and starts raising a family. In 2010, after she has the opportunity to interview war-crimes prosecutor Luc Côté about the recently-leaked "UN mapping report" (a report on war crimes in the DRC), she resumes writing about Africa.[22][23] The book then briefly catalogs some other RPF-related events that took place between 1998 and 2010, including French arrest warrants (2006), the Second Congo War (which Rever describes as a "looter's war"), and the Gersony report (leaked in 2010).

Full-time investigation after 2012

From 2012 onwards Rever devotes her career to a full-time investigation of RPF war crimes.[13] Much of Chapter 4 recounts stories from Théogène Murwanashyaka (TM), a former RPF army officer who reached out to her in 2012 and became a major informant of her book.[24] Unlike the RPF leadership, whose Tutsi families had fled Hutu rule to settle in Uganda, TM's family were what he called "interior Tutsis" – Tutsi families who had remained in Rwanda. TM came to believe that during the genocide "the RPF had sacrificed interior Tutsis" as a cost of gaining power.[20] Both TM and Belgian UNAMIR commander Luc Marchal, whom Rever interviewed, assert that the RPF could have done much to slow or stop the massacre of Tutsis by Hutus, but were more concerned with seizing power. According to Marchal, the goal was "to seize power and use the massacres as stock in trade to justify the military operations."[25]

Each of chapters 5 through 9 covers a different aspect of RPF actions during the Rwandan Civil War. Chapter 5[26] describes the RPF's use of military intelligence to destabilize the Habyarimana government and undermine the Arusha Peace Agreement. According to ICTR, these intelligence groups were responsible for most of the massacres of Hutu civilians attributed to the RPF.[27] They successfully infiltrated Hutu political parties and the extremist militia during the early 1990s. Citing ICTR testimony, the book says that before and during the genocide, RPF members who had infiltrated Hutu militia fueled the genocidal violence, including helping to kill Tutsi civilians at roadblocks.[28]

Chapters 6 through 10 describe alleged massacres of Hutus committed inside Rwanda by the RPF. Chapter 6,[29] based largely on ICTR information, describes a 1994 massacre of Hutu peasants in Byumba's football stadium. Chapter 7,[30] based largely on interviews, describes massacres of Hutus by RPF that allegedly occurred in Byumba's Karambi Trading Center, Murambi, and near Akagera National Park, where, according to Rever's informants, dead Hutus were concealed from satellite photography by being first burned and then buried.[31] In Chapters 8[32] and 9,[33] the book describes events at Giti, where the RPF allegedly massacred Hutus but then created a cover story about what happened. Rever also describes the participation of some non-RPF Tutsis in killing their Hutu neighbors, saying, "In 1994, Rwanda was awash in fear, mistrust, and paranoia."[34] Chapter 10[35] describes alleged RPF killings of Hutus inside Rwanda in 1996–1997, justified as "counterinsurgency" against Hutu genocidaires.

Chapters 11 and 12[36] deal with the International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda (ICTR), an international court established by the United Nations Security Council to judge people responsible for the Rwandan genocide and other serious violations of international law during 1994. In addition to its work identifying Hutu génocidaires who had committed war crimes against Tutsi, the ICTR gathered evidence of crimes by high-level RPF officers, but was then forbidden to indict RPF suspects. Instead, the ICTR was pressured by the US and the UN to hand over to Rwanda its evidence concerning RPF crimes. As a result, Rwanda prosecuted only two low-level soldiers for the killing on June 5, 1994 of several Hutu Catholic priests and a small child.

Chapter 13[37] presents the theory that the RPF, not Hutu extremists, shot down President Habyarimana's plane on 6 April 1994, using the ensuing chaos and mass killings to generate sympathy for its military campaign to seize power.[38]

In Chapter 14 "Becoming a target",[39] Rever describes threats against her safety and her family as she continues to publish articles criticizing the RPF. In 2015, she determines to fight back, by going to the press about the threats and by finishing the book.

Conclusions

Chapter 15[40] surveys a range of charges against the RPF beginning in 1991 and continuing to the 2019 conviction of Bosco Ntaganda for eighteen charges that included rape, murder, recruitment of child soldiers and sexual slavery of civilians. Rever criticizes many early reports from the 1990s as neglecting or even justifying deaths of Hutu civilians. Western nations, valuing Kagame's achievements as leader of Rwanda, remain donors and supporters despite the RPF's record on human rights.[41]

The book's conclusion stresses that bad actions by the RPF do not in any way justify or diminish the horror of the Rwanda genocide against Tutsis, saying:[42]

There is no part of this book that denies the genocide...There is no question that after Habyarimana's death, the [Hutu] hardliners chose genocide...But this book is not an examination of the dynamics of that 1994 genocide of Tutsis.

But she says that RPF "policy of ethnic murder" against Hutus should be considered a genocide as well.[42]

Her final message is that Rwanda cannot have true reconciliation as long as its government enforces secrecy about crimes committed by the RPF.[42] While suspects of the genocide against the Tutsi were tried and convicted by the ICTR, the crimes committed by the RPF have been left unpunished.[43][44]

Publishing history

The book was published by Random House of Canada in March 2018.[45] and in Dutch by Amsterdam University Press in 2018.[46] A French translation of the book was originally to be published by Fayard in 2019, but this company withdrew after controversy. Subsequently Max Milo published it in 2020 as Rwanda: L’éloge du sang (Rwanda: In Praise of Blood).[47][45][48]

Reception

Mainstream reviewers

In Rever's native Canada, the book's launch got attention, and Rever became a frequent interview subject, both on the book's contents and on her methods for writing it.[2][18][49] Both The Globe and Mail and the Toronto Star published book excerpts.[50][51]

One of the book's earliest reviews came in the LA Review of Books, "The Insistence of Memory," where political scientist Kate Cronin-Furman described the Rwandan government's use of memorial events "to remind Rwandans and the world that the Tutsi are never safe and that whatever the Kagame regime does is necessary for their protection"; in this context, she called In Praise of Blood "explosive."[52]

Helen Epstein, whose favorable two-part review for The New York Review of Books may have helped popularize the book,[53] wrote that Rever's "sources are too numerous and their observations too consistent for her findings to be a fabrication."[54] Epstein predicted, however, that the book would provoke significant pushback:[55]

Versions of Rever’s story have been told by others. While all contain convincing evidence against the RPF, some are marred by a tendency to understate the crimes of the Hutu génocidaires or overstate the RPF’s crimes. But some, including the work of Filip Reyntjens, a Belgian professor of law and politics, have been both measured and soundly researched. Kagame’s regime and its defenders have dismissed them all as propaganda spouted by defeated Hutu génocidaires and genocide deniers.

Science journalist Laurie Garrett, in a Lancet article sharply critical of Rwanda's leadership, called In Praise of Blood "expertly crafted, riveting, though often gruesome," calling it "excellent" both as journalism and as creative writing.[56] Similarly human rights scholar Jeff Bachman" called the book "investigative journalism at its finest," considering it "the most in-depth account yet of suspected crimes committed by Paul Kagame and the Rwandan Patriotic Front".[57]

Agnes Binagwaho and two other Rwanda-based academics criticized both Garrett's Lancet review and In Praise of Blood, saying that the book "propagates inaccuracies about the catalysing event of the 100 days of genocide against the Tutsis, blames the victims, and does not accurately discuss the rebuilding and reconciliation that has since occurred in Rwanda."[58]

Le Soir journalist Colette Braeckman praised Rever for her on-the-ground investigation but criticized the book for examining only one side of the coin--saying that, for example, it fails to note that the women and children refugees Rever met in Zaire could have been "human shields" for armed génocidaires. Braeckman also faulted the book for ignoring decades of anti-Tutsi racism when explaining the genocide and the RPF's actions.[6]

Scholarly

Political scientist René Lemarchand called the book a "path-breaking inquest", "destined to become required reading for any one claiming competence on the Rwanda genocide". He praised Rever for thorough investigation and taking risks in order to gather as much information as possible.[16] Scholar Filip Reyntjens said that the book fleshes out in "blood curdling detail" RPF violence that was already known in a general way.[59]

Historian Gerald Caplan criticized the book for "...too many unnamed informants; too many confidential, unavailable leaked documents; too much unexamined credulity about some of the accusations; too little corroboration from foreigners who were eyewitnesses to history."[60] Both Caplan and Linda Melvern found it concerning that the book's acknowledgments included alleged genocide-deniers.[61] Nevertheless, Caplan concluded "...Rever has reinforced the case against the RPF that had already been made and that left little doubt that the RPF under President Kagame is indeed guilty of war crimes, though not of genocide....I believe we all have an obligation to make this record better-known...[62]

Political scientist Timothy Longman said that Rever's book was "sensationalistic" and "provides only limited new information about RPF abuses within Rwanda", although elaborating on some cases described earlier by Alison Des Forges. Longman contends that "No academic has yet written a well-researched and detailed account of RPF violence, most likely because doing the necessary research would be both prohibitively difficult and extremely dangerous".[63]

Genocide

Linda Melvern criticized In Praise of Blood as "a sensationalist book," singling out for criticism material related to the 1994 genocide against Tutsis, particularly what she called "the noxious claim" that RPF commandos "infiltrated Hutu militia and 'assisted directly in killing Tutsi at roadblocks.'"[64]

Claudine Vidal wrote that "Rever's work blurs the line between investigation and indictment," pushing toward a declaration that there was a second "genocide," but with Hutu victims. According to Vidal, "Journalists and social scientists should be calling for investigations equivalent to those carried out into the Tutsi genocide, rather than .. trying to apply a particular legal classification"[44] Filip Reyntjens, responding to Vidal, gave his impression that the book's claim of "genocide" came from Rever's process of uncovering evidence, and was not the book's original or motivating argument.[65]

Political scientist Scott Straus, like Vidal, criticized the book for accusing the RPF of "genocide," while (also like Vidal) recognizing "the mass violence committed against Hutu populations in the 1990–1999 period." Straus called In Praise for Blood "irresponsible" and stated that Rever's "title is unnecessarily provocative, her tone breathless and conspiratorial."[66]

Yash Tandon criticized In Praise of Blood for overlooking the historical roots of the genocide against Tutsis. He questioned the book's "accusative approach" toward the RPF as a useful way forward in Hutu-Tutsi reconciliation efforts.[67]

Researchers Helen Hintjens and Jos van Oijen contested the likelihood that the RPF had concealed their killings of Hutus by cremating tens or hundreds of thousands of victims in Akagera National Park. Specialists they consulted, including the Netherlands Forensic Institute, concluded that the methods described by Rever "would certainly have left significant traces of mass murder," while two foreign observers saw no signs of "death camps" near the Gabiro army barracks.[9]

Researchers Bert Ingelaere and Marijke Verpoorten criticized the book as suggesting that "there in fact were two genocides happening at the time: one against the Tutsi, and one committed by Tutsi fighters and civilians against the Hutu." Citing their own research into inter-ethnic trust in Rwanda, they asserted that "If there had been a double genocide, one would expect to see Hutu levels of trust towards Tutsis to reach the same depths as those of Tutsi towards Hutu."[68]

In 2019, a group of sixty researchers and eye-witnesses including Romeo Dallaire published an open letter to complain that Belgian universities invited Rever to give talks about her book without providing any rebuttal viewpoints, giving the impression that they supported her theories.[69] In August, 2020, several organizations including Ibuka published an open letter to reproach Max Milo for publishing a French translation of the book, saying that it negated the Rwandan genocide by blaming Tutsis for the deaths of other Tutsis.[70]

Rever says she is not a genocide denier because she accepts that the killing of Tutsi was indeed a genocide,[2][71] but she is a "revisionist" because she questions existing historical narratives.[2]

Death toll

Estimates of Hutu deaths from mass violence in the 1990s are much less precise than Tutsi death figures from the Rwandan genocide due to the greater timescale and geographic spread of the killings.[72][73] Researcher Alison Des Forges estimated that the RPF killed 60,000 people in war crimes in 1994 and 1995.[73][72] Historian Gérard Prunier estimated that 100,000 Hutu were killed by the RPF in 1994–1995.[73] Historian Roland Tissot argued that there were around 400,000 Hutus killed by the RPF between 1994 and 1998 (excluding disease and excess mortality), while Omar Shahabudin McDoom estimated several hundred thousand Hutu victims during the 1990s.[73] Demographer Marijke Verpoorten guesstimates 542,000 deaths of Rwandan Hutus (about 7.5 percent of the population), with "a very large uncertainty interval", from war-related causes in the 1990s, including battle deaths and excess mortality from poor conditions in refugee camps.[74][72]

Awards

The Quebec Writers' Federation awarded IPOB its 2018 Mavis Gallant Prize for Non-Fiction, calling it "heartbreaking, chilling and necessary."[75][76] The book also won the Ontario Historical Society's 2018 Huguenot Society of Canada Award.[77] This award is given for bringing "public awareness to the principles of freedom of conscience and freedom of thought."[78] It was a finalist for the Hilary Weston Writers' Trust Prize for Nonfiction.[79] The jury's citation called In Praise of Blood "an undeniably important story told by a remarkably brave writer."[80] Canada's The Globe and Mail listed In Praise of Blood in its 2018 top-100 list of favourite books.[81] The Hong Kong Free Press named the book of its "Ten Best Human Rights Books of 2018," but said the book should be "in the running for bad cover of the year: not only does the cover have nothing to do with its subject, it is part of that old tradition of equating Africa with big wild animals."[15]

References

  1. ↑ Caplan 2018, p. 168.
  2. 1 2 3 4 "Canadian journalist challenges Rwandan genocide narrative in new book | CBC Radio". CBC. Retrieved 12 January 2021. Am I a revisionist? I guess I am because the official narrative of the genocide stipulates that there is basically one group of people who were targeted that's the Tutsis. And, in fact, that's not true. So there is a whole portion of history that's being concealed, that's been buried, and that needs to be revised. And I actually think that revising historical narratives is necessary because revisionism is the lifeblood of historical scholarship.
  3. ↑ Wachira, Charles (April 7, 2020). "Rwanda: Political opposition persists amid death, disappearance and detention". TowardFreedom.org. Retrieved December 26, 2020. Tutsi communities make up 14 percent of Rwanda's population, while Hutu communities make up 85 percent of the country's 12.6 million inhabitants. The Twa people make up the remaining one percent.
  4. ↑ "The Rwandan Genocide: How It Was Prepared: Context". Human Rights Watch. 2006. Retrieved December 26, 2020. In the mid-twentieth century, .. Hutu overthrew the Tutsi elite and established a Hutu-led republic...This event, known as the 1959 revolution, was remembered by Tutsi as a tragic and criminal event, while for Hutu it was seen as a heroic battle for liberation, to be celebrated with pride.
  5. ↑ "The Heart of the Hutu-Tutsi Conflict". PBS. October 8, 1999. Retrieved December 26, 2020. When Yoweri Museveni, a rebel leader of Tutsi descent, seized power in Uganda in 1986, it was largely through the assistance of Rwandan Tutsis. With a power base in Uganda, the Rwandan Tutsis formed the Rwandan Patriotic Front and began attacks against the Hutu-led government.
  6. 1 2 Braeckman, Colette (30 September 2020). ""L' Eloge du sang", une enquête fouillée mais controversée sur les crimes commis au Rwanda". Le Soir Plus (in French). Retrieved 10 November 2020. Mais le problème, c'est que Judi Rever, qui se défend cependant d'être négationniste et se contente d'assurer, à la fin de son livre, qu'elle reconnaît sans ambiguïté la réalité du génocide des Tutsis, n'aborde l'histoire que par un seul côté et omet le début. (But the problem is that Judi Rever, who denies being a negationist and is content to assure, at the end of her book, that she unambiguously recognizes the reality of the genocide of the Tutsis, approaches the story from one side only and omits the beginning.)
  7. ↑ Rever 2018, p. 8.
  8. ↑ Rever 2018, p. 48.
  9. 1 2 Hintjens, Helen M.; van Oijen, Jos (2020). "Elementary Forms of Collective Denial: The 1994 Rwanda Genocide". Genocide Studies International. 13 (2): 146–167. doi:10.3138/gsi.13.2.02. S2CID 216157285.
  10. ↑ Santoro, Lara (September 25, 2015). "Terror as Method: A Journalist's Search for Truth in Rwanda". Foreign Policy Journal. Retrieved December 27, 2020. Rever has since received what she believes are credible reports that the RPF intends to silence its critics in North America by staging traffic accidents—a method successfully employed in Africa—with the help of a former official at the Rwandan embassy in Ottawa. She and four other Canadians have gone to the press in an attempt to generate public awareness of their plight.
  11. ↑ Cribb, Robert; Black, Debra (April 11, 2015). "Four other Canadians believe they're being targeted by Rwanda". The Star. Retrieved December 27, 2020. Four other Canadians have said they are being targeted by Rwandan officials. Like Toronto-area lawyer Christopher Black, they are all vociferous critics of the Rwandan government and President Paul Kagame.
  12. ↑ Rever 2018, p. 150.
  13. 1 2 Rever 2018, p. 5.
  14. ↑ Rever 2018, p. 1–6, 220.
  15. 1 2 Kong, Tsung-Gan (January 1, 2019). "The ten best human rights books of 2018". Hong Kong Free Press. Retrieved December 28, 2020. Indeed, apart from the outstanding documentation the book provides, its other great value is to provide insight into the process of researching it. Rever writes about the regime's threats against her and the toll her investigations over many years took on her family and personal life.
  16. 1 2 Lemarchand, René (25 June 2018). "Rwanda: the state of Research". Violence de masse et Résistance – Réseau de recherche. Sciences Po. ISSN 1961-9898. Archived from the original on 19 November 2018. Retrieved 13 December 2018.
  17. ↑ Garrison, Ann (June 20, 2019). "In Praise of Blood: Crimes of the Rwandan Patriotic Front". Pambazuka News. Retrieved December 28, 2020. Her story begins in 1997, one week after Zaire's long-time dictator Mobutu Sese Seko was toppled by a coalition of Rwandan, Ugandan, and Congolese forces...The rest of the book is the story of how she researched and wrote it, and of her marriage, including the birth of her two daughters upon her return to Canada with her husband.
  18. 1 2 Patrick, Ryan B (October 9, 2018). "Judi Rever uncovers truths about the Rwandan genocide with In Praise of Blood". CBC.ca. Retrieved December 5, 2020. I decided on 10 or 15 chapters, and the chapters were created as scenes in the cinematic and visual sense. With each chapter, I wanted to not just explore a theme, but prove it as well. There was a cause-effect in each chapter, so I tried to find 10 to 15 ideas that would explore the human dilemma and then build a cinematic scene to depict it.
  19. ↑ Rever 2018, pp. 7–44.
  20. 1 2 Rever 2018, p. 40.
  21. ↑ Rever 2018, pp. 44–63.
  22. ↑ Rever 2018, p. 51.
  23. ↑ Rever, Judi (28 August 2010). "UN lawyer says Congo butchery resembled Rwandan genocide". Sydney Morning Herald. Retrieved 12 November 2020. In the aftermath, an estimated one million Rwandan Hutus left their homes and set up in UN-run refugee camps inside the Congolese border. Some of the refugees were guilty of genocide and secured weapons and training in the camps, but most of the refugees there were simply Hutus who feared violence and retribution in the homeland.
  24. ↑ Rever 2018, p. 55.
  25. ↑ Rever 2018, p. 62.
  26. ↑ Rever 2018, pp. 64–71.
  27. ↑ Rever 2018, p. 66.
  28. ↑ Rever 2018, p. 69, 142.
  29. ↑ Rever 2018, pp. 72–80.
  30. ↑ Rever 2018, pp. 81–105.
  31. ↑ Rever 2018, p. 76, 87, 229.
  32. ↑ Rever 2018, pp. 106–122.
  33. ↑ Rever 2018, pp. 123–130.
  34. ↑ Rever 2018, p. 106.
  35. ↑ Rever 2018, pp. 131–152.
  36. ↑ Rever 2018, pp. 153–176.
  37. ↑ Rever 2018, pp. 177–198.
  38. ↑ Rever 2018, p. 61, 231.
  39. ↑ Rever 2018, pp. 199–216.
  40. ↑ Rever 2018, pp. 217–228.
  41. ↑ Rever 2018, pp. 227–228.
  42. 1 2 3 Rever 2018, pp. 230.
  43. ↑ Rever 2018, p. 71.
  44. 1 2 Vidal, Claudine (10 July 2018). "Debate: Judi Rever will not let anything stand in the way of her quest to document a second Rwandan genocide". The Conversation. Retrieved 23 January 2021. It is enough to deem that the leaders of the FPR did indeed carry out a policy of terror by slaughtering Rwandan Hutus. In our view, there is no need for it to be genocide to justify investigation into these massacres. Furthermore, such investigations would in no way constitute a denial of the Tutsi genocide.
  45. 1 2 "Génocide des Tutsi au Rwanda : le livre controversé de Judi Rever paraîtra en France". Jeune Afrique (in French). 9 July 2020. Retrieved 10 November 2020.
  46. ↑ Judi Rever The Truth about Rwanda"
  47. ↑ "Judi Rever's disputed book on Tutsi genocide to be published in France". The Africa Report.com. 10 July 2020. Retrieved 10 November 2020.
  48. ↑ Rever, Judi (2020). Rwanda : L'éloge du sang: L'inconnu (in French). Max Milo. ISBN 978-2-315-00987-9.
  49. ↑ Cable Public Affairs Channel "Rwanda’s Hidden History: Investigation of a Second Genocide" (April 15, 2018)
  50. ↑ The Globe and Mail "Excerpt: In Praise of Blood and new revelations from the depths of the Rwandan genocide" (March 22, 2018)
  51. ↑ Toronto Star "Did Rwanda's Paul Kagame trigger the genocide of his own people?" (April 18, 2018)
  52. ↑ Cronin-Furman, Kate (May 16, 2018). "The Insistence of Memory". LA Review of Books. Retrieved January 3, 2021. Any mention of RPF atrocities meets with fury from the Kagame regime and determined disbelief from its admirers abroad. Yet incontrovertible evidence exists of massacres committed against Hutu populations in Rwanda and in refugee camps across the border in Zaire.
  53. ↑ Caplan 2018, p. 181.
  54. ↑ Epstein, Helen (June 7, 2018). "The Mass Murder We Don't Talk About". New York Review of Books. Retrieved December 2, 2020. Rever's account will prove difficult to challenge. She has been writing about Central Africa for more than twenty years, and her book draws on the reports of UN experts and human rights investigators, leaked documents from the International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda, and hundreds of interviews with eyewitnesses, including victims, RPF defectors, priests, aid workers, and officials from the UN and Western governments. Her sources are too numerous and their observations too consistent for her findings to be a fabrication.
  55. ↑ Epstein, Helen (June 28, 2018). "A Deathly Hush". New York Review of Books. Retrieved December 2, 2020. ... it's worth asking why the fiction has persisted that Kagame's RPF rescued Rwanda from further genocide when much evidence suggests that it actually helped provoke it by needlessly invading the country in 1990, massacring Hutus, probably shooting down the plane of President Juvénal Habyarimana in 1994, and failing to move swiftly to stop the genocide of the Tutsis, as Roméo Dallaire—commander of the UN peacekeeping force in Rwanda at the time—suggested in his memoir Shake Hands with the Devil.
  56. ↑ Garrett, Laurie (2018). "Rwanda: not the official narrative". The Lancet. 392 (10151): 909–912. doi:10.1016/S0140-6736(18)32124-X. S2CID 54384867. Rever's book, In Praise of Blood: The Crimes of the Rwandan Patriotic Front, is expertly crafted, riveting, though often gruesome, names names, and provides 33 pages of references and interview notes. As journalism and creative writing In Praise of Blood is excellent. But there is limited appetite for books about genocide, and this one will make nobody wealthy
  57. ↑ Bachman, Jeff (14 January 2020). "Judi Rever, "In Praise of Blood: The Crimes of the Rwandan Patriotic Front"". New Books Network. Retrieved 23 January 2021.
  58. ↑ Binagwaho, Agnes; Hinda, Ruton; Mills, Edward (2019). "Rwanda and revisionist history". The Lancet. 393 (10169): 319–320. doi:10.1016/S0140-6736(19)30121-7. PMID 30803716.
  59. ↑ Reyntjens, Filip (January 11, 2019). "De dubbele genocide van 1994". De Standaard (in Flemish). Retrieved 10 November 2020. Dat geeft vlees aan wat in meer algemene termen al eerder bekend was. Rever beschrijft in bloedstollend detail hoe het RPF slachtingen heeft aangericht onder ongewapende Hutu's – vrouwen en mannen, kinderen en bejaarden. (It fleshes out in clearer terms what was already known. Rever describes in blood-curdling detail how the RPF how the RPF wreaked havoc on unarmed Hutus – women and men, children and the elderly.)
  60. ↑ Caplan 2018, p. 184.
  61. ↑ Melvern, Linda (2020). Intent to Deceive: Denying the Genocide of the Tutsi. Verso Books. ISBN 978-1-78873-328-1.
  62. ↑ Caplan 2018, p. 187.
  63. ↑ Longman, Timothy (2020). "Twenty Years after Leave None to Tell the Story, What Do We Now Know about the Genocide of the Tutsi In Rwanda?". Journal of Humanitarian Affairs. 2 (2): 40–47. doi:10.7227/JHA.042.
  64. ↑ Melvern, Linda (April 8, 2020). "Moral Equivalence: The Story of Genocide Denial in Rwanda". Journal of International Peacekeeping. 22 (1–4): 190–198. doi:10.1163/18754112-0220104012. S2CID 218807021. Retrieved January 29, 2021. In a sensationalist book published in 2018 called In Praise of Blood ... made the noxious claim that during the genocide rpf commandos infiltrated Hutu militia and "'assisted directly in killing Tutsi at roadblocks"'
  65. ↑ Reyntjens, Filip. "Un " second génocide " au Rwanda : retour sur un débat complexe". The Conversation. Retrieved 10 November 2020. En 1994, tant Claudine Vidal que moi-même, ainsi que de nombreux autres, avons qualifié de génocide les crimes dont les Tutsis venaient d'être victimes, et cela avant la première enquête judiciaire, et a fortiori des poursuites et des condamnations judiciaires. C'était notre droit et notre devoir. Pourquoi Judi Rever n'aurait-t-elle pas aujourd'hui ce même droit et ce même devoir ? (In 1994, both Claudine Vidal and myself, as well as many others, qualified as genocide the crimes of which the Tutsis had just been victims, and that before the first judicial investigation, and a fortiori of the prosecutions and the judicial sentences. It was our right and our duty. Why shouldn't Judi Rever have this same right and this same duty today?)
  66. ↑ Straus, Scott (2019). "The Limits of a Genocide Lens: Violence Against Rwandans in the 1990s". Journal of Genocide Research. 21 (4): 504–524. doi:10.1080/14623528.2019.1623527. S2CID 196571351.
  67. ↑ Tandon, Yash (September 26, 2019). "A pan-African perspective on Rwanda through a critical review of Judy Rever, In Praise of Blood: The Crimes of the Rwandan Patriotic Front, Canada, Random House, 2018". Pambazuka. Retrieved January 20, 2021. In her book, Judy Revers has overlooked the institutional and cultural carnage left behind by the imperialists. Furthermore, by adopting an accusative approach .. Rever lost an opportunity of joining forces that are seeking to leave behind the Hutu-Tutsi genocidal recent history in order to move forward. Indeed, the genocides should be a kind of a lighthouse – warning people against moving in that direction.
  68. ↑ Ingelaere, Bert; Verpoorten, Marijke. "How trust returned to Rwanda, for most but not for all". African Arguments. Retrieved 17 November 2020. In a recent article, we studied the impact of the 1994 genocide on trust in Rwanda. We analysed more than 400 life history interviews, spanning from before the genocide up to 17 years after it. For each year, the participants, a mix of people that explicitly self-identified as Hutu or Tutsi, indicated their level of inter- and intra-ethnic trust.
  69. ↑ "Rwanda: pétition contre des conférences révisionnistes sur le Rwanda". LeSoir (in French). 9 October 2019. Retrieved 17 November 2020.
  70. ↑ "Génocide contre les Tutsis : Max Milo ne doit pas publier un ouvrage négationniste (Genocide against Tutsis: Max Milo should not publish a negationist book". Liberation.fr (in French). August 15, 2020. Retrieved January 20, 2021. Judi Rever se défend évidemment de tout négationnisme. Elle consent à reconnaître que des Tutsis ont été massacrés en 1994 au Rwanda… mais par d'autres Tutsis. (Judi Rever says she is not a negationist. She consents to recognize that some Tutsis were massacred in 1994 in Rwanda – but by other Tutsis.
  71. ↑ Caplan 2018, p. 169.
  72. 1 2 3 Meierhenrich, Jens (2020). "How Many Victims Were There in the Rwandan Genocide? A Statistical Debate". Journal of Genocide Research. 22 (1): 72–82. doi:10.1080/14623528.2019.1709611. S2CID 213046710.
  73. 1 2 3 4 Guichaoua, André (2020). "Counting the Rwandan Victims of War and Genocide: Concluding Reflections". Journal of Genocide Research. 22 (1): 125–141. doi:10.1080/14623528.2019.1703329. S2CID 213471539.
  74. ↑ Verpoorten, Marijke (2020). "How Many Died in Rwanda?". Journal of Genocide Research. 22 (1): 94–103 [94]. doi:10.1080/14623528.2019.1703253. hdl:10067/1652630151162165141. S2CID 213108505.
  75. ↑ "The Mavis Gallant Prize for Non-Fiction – Quebec Writers' Federation". Quebec Writers' Federation. Retrieved 11 November 2020.
  76. ↑ "Winner of The Mavis Gallant Prize for Non-Fiction in 2018". Quebec Writers Federation. 2018. Retrieved December 29, 2020. This book is heartbreaking, chilling and necessary.
  77. ↑ "OHS Huguenot Award Recognizes Judi Rever for In Praise of Blood" (PDF). Ontario Historical Society. 19 June 2019. Retrieved 10 November 2020.
  78. ↑ "OHS Huguenot Award Recognizes Judi Rever for In Praise of Blood" (PDF). Ontario Historical Society. June 15, 2019. Retrieved December 29, 2020. The Huguenot Society of Canada Award honours the best book—or substantial article—published in Ontario within the last three years that has brought public awareness to the principles of freedom of conscience and freedom of thought. The 2018 recipient is Judi Rever, for her book In Praise of Blood: The Crimes of the Rwandan Patriotic Front, published by Random House Canada...The book is investigative journalism of the highest order.
  79. ↑ Patrick, Ryan B (September 20, 2017). "Terese Marie Mailhot, Elizabeth Hay among finalists for $60K Hilary Weston Writers' Trust Prize for Nonfiction". CBC. Retrieved December 2, 2020.
  80. ↑ "Judi Rever | Writers' Trust of Canada". Judi Rever | Writers' Trust of Canada. Retrieved 10 November 2020. A dogged reporter and skillful writer, Rever eschews what she calls the 'Hollywood version of good guys and bad guys' to meticulously document a chapter in recent history that is as complicated as it is dismaying.
  81. ↑ "The Globe 100: Our favourite books of 2018". Globe and Mail. November 30, 2018. Retrieved January 22, 2021. Montreal-based journalist Judi Rever offers an authoritative account in her new book, sourced from 200-plus interviews and detailed documents leaked from the International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda.

Sources

Further reading

This article is issued from Wikipedia. The text is licensed under Creative Commons - Attribution - Sharealike. Additional terms may apply for the media files.