Development

In 1952 Ida Lupino expressed interest in obtaining the film rights, as a possible vehicle for Robert Mitchum.^[8][9]

In 1955 Filmmakers Inc announced they would make the film along with an adaptation of The Quick and the Dead.^[10]

20th Century Fox bought the film rights in March 1958 following the success of the film of Old Yeller.^[11] It was assigned to prolific producer Jerry Wald who hired director Don Siegel. Siegel later wrote "I had never done a picture in this genre. It was a welcome change of pace to directed a film that children could go see. I wish I could do more. My reputation may be as a director of violence.... but that doesn't mean I can't, or don't want to do comedy, or love stories. My favourite picture is Brief Encounter."^[7]

Gipson was signed to write the script. According to his biographer "changes in the story of Blackie Scanlon incite Gipson to uncontrollable rages and Tommie Gipson [his wife] arbitrates all further revisions." (The author would later be given shock treatment for depression and imprisoned for assault.)^[12]

Casting

Ricky Nelson, Lyndsay Crosby, and David Ladd were mentioned early on as possible stars, along with Stuart Whitman, who did wind up playing the title role.^[13] Tuesday Weld was at one stage mentioned as a possible female lead.^[14] Whitman was cast in March 1959.^[15]

The movie eventually became a starring vehicle for Fabian, who had released a series of hit singles. 20th Century Fox had enjoyed success launching pop stars Elvis Presley and Pat Boone into film careers and thought they could do the same with Fabian.^[16] He was paid $35,000 for ten weeks work.^[17]

Siegel said Wald wanted Fabian to "sing at least twelve songs in the picture. Fabian, though one of the nicest kids I ever mat, couldn't sing and knew it... I wanted to make Fred Gipson's excellent novel into a film which didn't feature any songs. Wald turned me down flat."^[7]

Wald tried to get Jayne Mansfield to play the part of a blousy barmaid but was unsuccessful.^[18]

Dodie Stevens was cast because Wald's teenage sons liked her song "Pink Shoe Laces".^[19]

Shooting

Filming started July 27, 1959 and took place through August and September.^[20]

Siegel said he "decided to have as much fun with the picture as possible. All but one of Fabian's songs were interrupted abruptly."^[7] This happens four times in the movie.^[21]

LQ Jones later recalled that Fabian "was not that talented as an actor, but he worked hard and was just a nice person."^[22] Siegel wrote that "Wald seemed puzzled at how easily the picture went together."^[7]

Box Office

The film was not a commercial success, failing to make the Variety list of films that earned $1 million or more in rentals for 1959.^[25]

Fox executives later put this down to public rejection of Fabian, in particular the fact that his fans were very young and not ticket-buying teenagers.^[16]

Critical

According to one review it was a "slice-of-life, coming-of-age piece – a little hunting, some singing, Claude Akins pops around periodically to snarl at Whitman, Lynley pants over Whitman as does Akins’ wife. There’s a comic doctor, a dog, a barn dance. It’s actually a sweet film – well made, with great production values, and a very strong cast."^[21]

Siegel said "it's difficult to get over in a precis the fun, the beauty, the splendid acting, the wondrous feeling of robust freedom in Hound Dog Man" calling Whitman "a brilliant actor."^[7] However he also added "Sam Peckinpah wanted to do a picture based strictly on the book. I'm sorry he didn't do it. He would have done it the way it should have been made - small."^[7]

However, Fox later found Fabian could be effective in supporting roles of major stars for the studios, such as John Wayne in North to Alaska and Bing Crosby in High Time.

Fabian later reflected in 1971 that he thought the title was to blame for the film's poor box office reception. "It was a good story with a great cast... but "Hound Dog Man"?"^[26]