Anchors

At the time of the Greeley Mall opening, there were only three anchor stores: Joslin's, Montgomery Ward, and J.M. McDonalds (a department store not to be confused with the restaurant chain, McDonald's) that briefly had a different name at the time of mall opening. Sears and an extension of the mall were built on the north side of the mall in 1981.^[4] This new wing contained a Radio Shack and a toy store named Three Wishes. JCPenney, the last anchor store, was relocated from downtown Greeley in 1987 and built on the south west portion of the mall.^[5] The original main entrance to the Greeley Mall had been on the north side where this Sears and outcropping was built. Dillard's opened at Greeley Mall in 1998 after buying out Mercantile Stores, Inc., owner of the Joslin's brand at the time;^[6] similar to other instances where Dillard's bought out other brands, Dillard's occupied two store fronts (referred to as Dillard's East and Dillard's South), closing both in 2008 by May 14.^[7] AtHome began the process of opening in the former Dillard's East in 2015,^[8] softly opening on Thursday, July 28 and having its grand opening on August 8;^[9][10] it was short lived with AtHome announcing a relocation in 2020 and moving to Johnstown, Colorado in February 2021.^[11] Sears closed in January 2018,^[12] and it was demolished in 2019.^[13] JCPenney closed in 2020 after filing for bankruptcy.^[14]

Other smaller tenants

Some of the early notable stores in the Greeley Mall were Barbary Cheese, Balanced Diet, Carousel, Zezo's Magic Castle, Foxxmore, Stuarts, Frankies, Qualitat Unlimited, Martin's Shoes, Kenney's Shoes and Natural Music, and organ store. There was also a Regency Hallmark store that had two mall openings with a bridge that was a shortcut between two mall sections, a store selling pewter goods and a candle store called Candle Junction and a Record Bar store. In the hallway toward the east in the J.M. McDonald's store wing was a pinball arcade named Land of Odds.

The mall did not have a food court at the time it was built, but there was a cantina named Godinez that had an outside entrance that faced the north, Dairy Queen, and an Arby's that had a back door exit that was on the south side. There was a Karmelkorn store in the center of the mall that was the longest standing tenant and an Orange Julius with a Devil themed decor. Interestingly enough, Frankies toys/novelties that was on the west of the end of the mall was the largest tenant for many years. Breslers 33 flavors was an ice cream store in a kiosk in the mall that disappeared after the 1986 remodel.

Today there is exactly one anchor left - Cinemark which was built in 2003-04 as part of the 2004 expansion^[15] and replaced the Montgomery Ward building.^[16] Spirit Halloween also has been switching between both the former Team Tom Gym/Dillard's Space (2020) and the AtHome/Dillard's space (2021).^[17]

The (Strip) Mall Behind the Mall

Greeley Mall has a strip mall east of the former Joslin's that was also built in 1973; it sits along the edge of Hwy 34 and 17th Avenue.^[5] This complex contained a Safeway store (previously occupied by Office Depot^[5] and Habitat for Humanity/Home Improvement Outlet)^[4] with an attached Daylight Donuts and a hallway, a Stockfleth hardware store and various other stores in this small strip. To this day, the Safeway store sits vacant. As of 2019, the rest of the building contains (from west to east) Starlight Station, Iglesia De Dios, and Wholesale Hydroponics.^[18] It sits to the south of highway 34 on the edge of 17th avenue.

There was a movie theater just south of the complex that was built in 1977 that still remains today. There is also a former CNB Bank/Bank of the West/First National Bank^[4] that was built as a bank in 1973 and still stands today; it is occupied by Coin Laundry. Once, there even was a long-since-removed Fotomat that sat between Safeway and the CNB bank. There was also some form of a Coffee Shop that sat just north of the theatre.^[5]

New restaurants

There were no buildings between 23rd avenue and the main mall to the west until about 1980 around time of the Sears construction. Restaurants that stand today include Pizza Hut (built 1995),^[4] Olive Garden (built 2002), and Chuck E. Cheese (built 2005)^[5]

Competition beyond the mall

There was minimal/no competition across 23rd Avenue toward the west until the 80s; before various retail giants popped up, the land was made up of only cornfields and farmers properties, no retail competition at that time. Today, the space is occupied by Tractor Supply Co and Gold's Gym (former Hobby Lobby Creative Center) that was built in 1986 as Walmart (which moved just south to a new building to switch to a super center in 1994),^[19] Habitat for Humanity ReStore and ttec that made up the former Super Kmart Center built in 1994, and other various stores, restaurants, and a theatre in the area.^[5]