Origin and If These Streets Could Talk (2003–2005)

Just Surrender was formed in 2003 while the members were still attending high school.^[1] guitarist & vocalist Dan Simons says he was inspired by 70s and 80s bands such as Journey, Bon Jovi & Poison, Just Surrender's first compilation was a 4-song EP. Many of the songs written for the EP were re-recorded for their first full album, If These Streets Could Talk, which was released by the EastWest Records subsidiary Broken English in 2005.^[7] Recording took place at Nada Recording Studios in New York with the producer John Naclerio. The band and its first album appeared on MTV's You Heard It Here First. In reviewing the album, the music critic Kate Lohnes wrote, "Overall, Just Surrender has panache. There's talent backing this heartfelt, although slightly unoriginal, release."^[8] The critic, Christopher Felton described the album as "unfortunately nothing more than a half-decent attempt at copying the work of far more superior bands".^[9]

Touring and increased popularity (2005–2007)

The band quickly became popular on the music site PureVolume and received more than 400,000 plays in a matter of months.^[5]

In 2005, Meunier left the band, and was replaced by Alex Haycraft. On March 7, 2008, Meunier returned . The band sent in a statement to bsolutePunk that reads, "Just Surrender fans may have noticed on recent tours that original guitarist Andy Meunier has returned to the band. Alex Haycraft (formerly of Park) has moved over to bass."

We're in Like Sin and Stronger Now EP (2007–2009)

Just Surrender released the song "Body Language and Bad Habits" on its MySpace page on July 1, 2007. The song is from the album We're in Like Sin, released on August 21, 2007. The album charted at number 27 on the Heatseekers Albums chart.^[10] In reviewing the album, AbsolutePunk wrote, "Though not necessarily bigger, and far from innovative, We’re In Like Sin is a worthy follow-up."^[11] Wonka Vision called it a "pop-punk" "guilty pleasure".^[12]

Just Surrender embarked on a Northeastern and Midwestern tour in January 2009 alongside Jesse Barrera of My American Heart, Patent Pending, Kelsey & the Chaos and Pull the Pin.^[13] After the addition and returning from the UK they wrote and recorded for an EP titled Stronger Now that was released on July 9, 2009. It was only made available at Warped Tour however, until released by iTunes on August 12. Stronger Now is significantly heavier than previous albums and has been described as post-hardcore.

In November 2009, the band joined Hawthorne Heights for the Never Sleep Again tour.

With another line-up change, Haycraft and Meunier left the band. Kyle Shellhammer (formerly of The High Court) became the band's bass guitarist, with Jolly Ubriaco as lead guitarist.

Phoenix and rumored indefinite hiatus (2010–2011)

On June 22, 2010, Just Surrender released a third full-length album called Phoenix.^[14] Two tracks, "Burning Up (Acoustic)" and "On My Own" have been released. It contains 12 tracks, including two previously released on the Stronger Now EP: the songs "Crazy" and "Stronger Now".^[15] That same day, a music video was released for "On My Own".^[16]

On June 10, 2010, the band released a statement on its Facebook page saying that Phoenix would be released June 22, 2010, through iTunes, and would be released through retail on July 13, 2010. "Take Me Home", the band's next single, was released on June 15 through iTunes as scheduled. Just Surrender then toured with Hit The Lights and The Maine on the Zumiez Couch Tour.^[17] The album was released and received positive criticism.

There was a rumor that after touring, Just Surrender would be going on indefinite hiatus. That was disputed by the band members' Facebook posts. A post by the band on Facebook strongly hinted towards an indefinite hiatus:

"To all the fans that support us, thanks

If you were kind enough to lend us your floor, Thanks. We have been doing this thing for close to 10 years, and despite every major publication telling us that we’re a generic band with bad lyrics, some of you have taken those songs and made them the soundtrack to your lives. Thank you very much. I don’t really know what the future holds for Just Surrender. Anytime you involve lawyers, money, and contract disputes, the outcome is always painful. The music business is a gamble, and usually 9/10 don’t last. I’m glad we got to make 3 records and share our lives with you. To all the bands that we have shared the stage with, sorry for drinking all the beer.

Come check out a show, before it’s too late!"^[18]

Despite rumored hiatus, Just Surrender has played many live shows since 2011.

Fourth studio album (2011–2014)

On December 19, it was reported that Just Surrender were writing material for a new album which would be self-released, and that Ryan Kienle, formerly of Matchbook Romance, was the band's new bass guitarist.^[19] Pitchfork revealed a release of the new album set for fall 2012. Simons said in a 2018 interview with American Slacker Podcast that the band had secretly gone into indefinite hiatus in 2013 but agreed that they would continue to write new material for the project while re-grouping.^[20]

Resurgence (2015–)

On January 20, 2015, Maffucci announced on Facebook that the band had officially been released from its contract with Razor and Tie Record Company and would be recording a new EP to be released in summer 2015.^[21] After its 2017 re-grouping, the band recruited ex-Houston Calls drummer Josh Grigsby to fill in for Miller during live shows and touring because of Miller's tight schedule