Aberdeen

Travers coached in Norway and was trainer then player-manager of Dumbarton before being engaged to coach Aberdeen in 1922.^[7] He remained in that position until the retirement of Philip in the summer of 1924.^[2] One of his first acts as manager was the signing of Alec Jackson, together with his brother George. Jackson went on to be one of the most renowned players of his generation. In spite of this, however, Travers' first season in charge ended with relegation only avoided on goal difference. In the following seasons, many players came and went – Travers worked hard in the transfer market of the time, and his dealings are credited with improving the club's previously precarious financial situation.

In 1931, Travers mysteriously dropped three of the club's regular players before a match against Falkirk. In all, five players never played for the club again,^[2] and it was reported in the 1970s that this was the result of an alleged plot to win fixed-odds bets on half-time and full-time scores. No police action was ever taken, and many of those involved protested their innocence for the remainder of their lives. The same year, he brought Donald Colman to the club from Dumbarton to act as a coach.^[7]

In 1937, Travers took his team to the Scottish Cup final, the first time Aberdeen had ever appeared in the event. They were defeated 2–1 by Celtic in front of a record official attendance of 146,433, although many more spectators may have gained illegal entry. That summer, the club were on a tour of South Africa when outside-right Jackie Benyon died suddenly of peritonitis. Travers remained in charge for two more seasons, but feeling that he no longer had the full support of his directors, accepted an offer to manage Clyde in 1938; he was replaced at Aberdeen by Colman.

Clyde

The success which had eluded him at Pittodrie soon materialised at Shawfield, however, and the Scottish Cup was won by Travers' Clyde team in 1938–39. He was still manager of Clyde in 1954–55, when the Bully Wee beat Celtic in a replay to win their second Cup. He was also a runner up as manager with Clyde in the Scottish Cup in 1948–49 when Clyde lost 4–1 to Rangers in the final.

Also notably in season 1951–52, Travers led Clyde to four trophies in a single season; the Scottish Division B league title, the B Division Supplementary Cup, the Glasgow Cup and the Glasgow Merchants Charity Cup.^[8]

His four Scottish Cup finals earned him a reputation as a "Cup specialist" when named as one of Scotland's 50 greatest managers by the Sunday Herald newspaper.^[9][10]

Player

Thornliebank

• Renfrewshire Victoria Cup: 1902–03,^[17] 1903–04^[18]

Renton

• Dumbartonshire Cup: 1907–08^[19]

Aberdeen

• Scottish Division One: Runners-up 1910–11^[20]
• North East Cup: 1913–14^[21]

Celtic

• Scottish Cup: 1911–12^[20]
• Scottish Division One: Runners-up 1911–12

Dumbarton

• Dumbartonshire Cup: 1914–15^[22]
• Dumbartonshire Charity Cup: 1916–17^[23]

Clydebank

• Dunbartonshire Cup: 1917–18^[24]
• Clydebank Charity Cup: 1917–18^[25]

Manager

Dumbarton

• Dumbartonshire Cup: 1921–22^[26]
• Dumbartonshire Charity Cup: 1921–22^[27]

Aberdeen

• Scottish Cup: Runner-up: 1936–37
• Aberdeenshire Cup (10) : 1924–25, 1925–26, 1926–27, 1927–28, 1928–29, 1929–30, 1930–31, 1931–32, 1932–33, 1933–34^[28]
• Aberdeenshire League (4): 1925–26, 1926–27, 1927–28, 1928–29^[29]
• Dewar Shield (8): 1926–27, 1928–29, 1930–31, 1931–32, 1932–33, 1933–34, 1935–36, 1936–37^[30]

Clyde

• Scottish Cup: 1938–39, 1954–55
  • Runner-up: 1948–49
• Scottish B Division: 1951–52
• Supplementary Cup: 1951–52^[31]
• Glasgow Cup: 1946–47,^[32] 1951–52^[33]
• Glasgow Charity Cup: 1939–40,^[34] 1951–52^[35]
• Paisley Charity Cup: 1938–39,^[36] 1939–40^[37]