Whitman c. 1860

Lincoln in February 1865, two months before his death

The American poet Walt Whitman greatly admired Abraham Lincoln, the 16th president of the United States, and was deeply affected by his assassination, writing several poems as elegies and giving a series of lectures on Lincoln. The two never met. Shortly after Lincoln was killed in April 1865, Whitman hastily wrote the first of his Lincoln poems, "Hush'd Be the Camps To-Day". In the following months, he wrote two more: "O Captain! My Captain!" and "When Lilacs Last in the Dooryard Bloom'd". Both appeared in his collection Sequel to Drum-Taps later that year. The poems—particularly "My Captain!"—were well received and popular upon publication and, in the following years, Whitman styled himself as an interpreter of Lincoln. In 1871, his fourth poem on Lincoln, "This Dust Was Once the Man", was published, and the four were grouped together as the "President Lincoln's Burial Hymn" cluster in Passage to India. In 1881, the poems were republished in the "Memories of President Lincoln" cluster of Leaves of Grass.

From 1879 to 1890, Whitman's lectures on Lincoln's assassination bolstered the poet's own reputation and that of his poems. Critical reception to Whitman's Lincoln poetry has varied since their publication. "My Captain!" was very popular, particularly before the mid-20th century, and is still considered one of his most popular works, despite slipping in popularity and critical assessment since the early 1900s. "Lilacs" is often listed as one of Whitman's finest works.

Background

Whitman (left) and Lincoln (right) c. 1854 when they were 35 and 45 years old respectively

Whitman and Lincoln

In 1856, Whitman wrote a lengthy description of his ideal president: a "heroic" figure who was cunning and bold in temperament and knowledgeable about the world; a "Lincolnesque figure" according to Whitman biographer Justin Kaplan. He also opined on this hypothetical president's physical attributes: bearded and dressed in "a clean suit of working attire". Whitman explicitly mentions blacksmiths and boatmen as ideal precursor occupations.^[18][19] Two years later, Whitman first mentioned Lincoln by name in writing.^[18] That year, he supported Stephen Douglas over Lincoln for election to the United States Senate.^[20] Whitman first saw Lincoln as the president-elect traveled through New York City on February 19, 1861.^[21] Whitman noticed Lincoln's "striking appearance" and "unpretentious dignity", and trusted his "supernatural tact" and "idiomatic Western genius".^[22] Whitman's admiration of Lincoln steadily grew in the following years;^[23][24] in October 1863 Whitman wrote in his diary "I love the President personally."^[25]

Shown in the presidential booth of Ford's Theatre (left to right: assassin John Wilkes Booth, Abraham Lincoln, Mary Todd Lincoln, Clara Harris, and Henry Rathbone)

Although they never met, Whitman estimated in a letter he saw Lincoln about twenty to thirty times between 1861 and 1865, sometimes at close quarters.^[22][26] Lincoln passed Whitman several times and nodded to him, interactions that Whitman detailed in letters to his mother. Lincoln biographer William Barton writes there was little "evidence of recognition", and Lincoln likely nodded to many passersby as he traveled.^[27] Whitman and Lincoln were in the same room twice: at a reception in the White House following Lincoln's first inauguration in 1861, and when Whitman visited John Hay, Lincoln's private secretary, at the White House.^{[lower-alpha 1][29]}

In August 1863, Whitman wrote in The New York Times, "I see the president almost every day".^[24] Later that year, Whitman wrote a letter about Lincoln in which he described the president's face as a "Hoosier Michel Angelo, so awful ugly it becomes beautiful". In the letter he described Lincoln as captaining the "ship of state".^[30] Whitman considered himself and Lincoln to be "afloat in the same stream" and "rooted in the same ground".^[22] They shared similar views on slavery and the Union—both men opposed allowing slavery to expand across the US but considered preservation of the Union more important.^[31] Whitman was a consistent supporter of Lincoln's politics, and similarities have been noted in their literary styles and inspirations. Whitman later said that, "Lincoln gets almost nearer me than anybody else."^[32][22][24]

It remains unclear how much Lincoln knew about Whitman, though he knew of him and his admiration for him.^[24] There is an account of Lincoln reading Leaves of Grass in his office, and another of the president saying "Well, he looks like a man!" upon seeing Whitman in Washington, D.C., but these accounts may be fictitious.^[22][33] Whitman was present at Lincoln's second inauguration in 1865 and left D.C. shortly after to visit his family.^[34]

On April 15, 1865, shortly after the end of the American Civil War, Lincoln was assassinated.^[35] Whitman was residing in Brooklyn while on a break from his job at the Department of the Interior when he heard the news. He recalled that although breakfast was served, the family did not eat and "not a word was spoken all day".^[36]

Whitman's poetry on Abraham Lincoln

The first poem that Whitman wrote on Lincoln's assassination was "Hush'd Be the Camps To-Day", dated April 19, 1865—the day of Lincoln's funeral in Washington.^{[lower-alpha 2][37]} Near the publication of Drum-Taps, Whitman decided the collection would be incomplete without a poem on Lincoln's death and hastily added "Hush'd Be the Camps To-Day".^[41] He halted further distribution of the work and stopped publication on May 1,^[42] primarily to develop his Lincoln poems.^[43] He followed that poem with "O Captain! My Captain!" and "When Lilacs Last in the Dooryard Bloom'd".^[37] "My Captain" first appeared in The Saturday Press on November 4, 1865,^[16][44] and was published with "Lilacs" in Sequel to Drum-Taps around the same time. Although Sequel to Drum-Taps had been published in early October,^[45] copies were not ready for distribution until December,^[38] and English professor Amanda Gailey described Whitman's decision to publish "My Captain" in The Saturday Press as a teaser for Sequel.^[16]

In 1866, Whitman's friend William D. O'Connor published The Good Gray Poet: A Vindication, a short, promotional work for Whitman. O'Connor presented Whitman as Lincoln's "foremost poetic interpreter", proclaiming "Lilacs" as "the grandest and the only grand funeral music poured around Lincoln's bier".^[46]

Whitman did not compose "This Dust was Once the Man", his fourth on Lincoln, until 1871.^[47][48][49] The four poems were first grouped together in the "President Lincoln's Burial Hymn" cluster of Passage to India (1871). Ten years later, in a later edition of Leaves of Grass, the grouping was named "Memories of President Lincoln".^[39][50] The poems were not revised substantially following their publication.^{[lower-alpha 3][52]}

Whitman wrote two other poems on Lincoln's assassination that were not included in the cluster.^[53] Shortly before Whitman's death, he wrote a final poem with the president as its subject, titled "Abraham Lincoln, Born Feb. 12, 1809", in honor of Lincoln's birthday.^[54] It appeared in the New York Herald on February 12, 1888.^[55] The poem has only two lines and is not well known.^[54]

Lectures

An announcement of Whitman's lecture at Madison Square Theatre

In 1875, Whitman published Memoranda During the War. The book, a collection of diary entries, includes a telling of Lincoln's assassination from the perspective of someone who was present. The New York Sun published that section in 1876 to a positive reception. Whitman, by then in failing health, presented himself as neglected, unfairly criticized, and deserving of pity in the form of financial aid.^[56] Richard Watson Gilder and several of Whitman's other friends soon suggested he give a series of "Lincoln Lectures" aimed at raising both funds and Whitman's profile. Whitman adapted his New York Sun article for the lectures.^[57]

Whitman gave a series of lectures on Lincoln from 1879 to 1890. They centered on the assassination but also covered the years leading up to and during the American Civil War. Whitman occasionally gave poetry readings, such as "O Captain! My Captain!". The lectures were generally popular and well received.^[58][59] In 1980, Whitman biographer Justin Kaplan wrote that Whitman's 1887 lecture in New York City and its after-party marked the closest he came to "social eminence on a large scale".^[60]

In 1885, Whitman contributed an essay about his experiences with Lincoln to a volume being compiled by Allen Thorndike Rice.^[61] Novelist Bram Stoker gave at least one lecture on Lincoln and discussed the deceased president with Whitman in November 1886. The two met when Stoker wrote a lengthy letter to Whitman in 1872 and were friends thereafter. Robert J. Havlik in the Walt Whitman Quarterly wrote that their "mutual respect for Lincoln" was a foundation of their relationship.^[62][63]

Reception

The title page of Sequel to Drum-Taps

The cluster of poems improved Whitman's reputation,^[64] and included one considered by critics to be his best ("Lilacs") and one of his most popular ("My Captain!").^[42][65][66] Historian Roy Basler deemed "My Captain!" and "Lilacs" Whitman's two most famous poems.^[67] The scholar William Pannapacker called "My Captain" the most popular poem ever written on Lincoln.^[68]

Drum-Taps and Sequel received mixed reviews from critics following their publication.^[69] Some poems were generally praised; particularly "My Captain!" and, to a lesser extent, "Lilacs".^[70] Henry James accused Whitman of exploiting the tragedy of Lincoln's death to serve himself.^[69] Conversely, after reading Sequel to Drum-Taps, author William Dean Howells became convinced that Whitman had cleaned his "old channels of their filth" and poured "a stream of blameless purity" through; he would become a prominent defender of Whitman.^[71][72] Whitman's Lincoln poetry was not immediately popular.^[73] His lectures helped to raise the perception of the poems around the nation, and by the late 1870s "My Captain" was often listed with James Russell Lowell's "Commemoration Ode" as some of the best poetry honoring Lincoln.^[74] As Whitman's profile grew, many people assumed he had been close to the president during his life.^[75]

After 1881, Whitman became known increasingly for "My Captain!" and the persona he cultivated through events like the lectures.^[76] "My Captain!" became Whitman's most popular poem; it was his only poem to be anthologized before his death.^[77] Following Whitman's death in 1892, his obituary in the New York Herald noted that to most people "Whitman's poetry will always remain as a sealed book, but there are few who are not able to appreciate the beauty of 'O Captain! My Captain!'"^[78] In 1920, Léon Bazalgette, a French literary critic, wrote "Lilacs" and "My Captain!" had established Whitman as the poet "who sings the American nation" and that his Lincoln poems represented "the heart of America in tears".^[79] In 1943, Henry Seidel Canby wrote that Whitman's poems on Lincoln have become known as "the poems of Lincoln".^[80]

Opinions of "My Captain!" and "Commemoration Ode" remained high until the 20th century. Following a critical reappraisal, critics wrote about the poems' conventionality and lack of originality.^[74][81] "Lilacs" superseded them as one of the most prominent poems of the Civil War era.^[74] In 1962, Whitman biographer James E. Miller described several poems in the cluster as "competently executed expressions of public sentiment on a high public occasion", but lacking the sentimentality and powerful symbolism of "Lilacs".^[82] The scholar of American literature Charles M. Oliver wrote in 2006 that Whitman's works on Lincoln represent him at his most eloquent.^[83]

Analysis

Whitman as interpreter of Lincoln

A depiction of George Washington welcoming Abraham Lincoln into Heaven. Whitman owned a copy of this image and displayed it at his home in Camden.^[85]

Shortly after Lincoln's assassination, hundreds of poems were composed about his death. Historian Stephen B. Oates wrote that the American public had never mourned the death of a head of state so deeply.^[68] Whitman was ready and willing to write poetry on the topic,^[86] seizing the opportunity to present himself as an "interpreter of Lincoln" to increase the readership of Leaves of Grass while honoring a man he admired.^[87] In 2004, Pannapacker described the poetry as a "mixture of innovation and opportunism".^[67] Scholar Daniel Aaron writes that "Whitman placed himself and his work in the reflected limelight" of Lincoln's death.^[86]

The work of poets like Whitman and Lowell helped to establish Lincoln as the "first American", epitomizing the newly reunited America.^[88] Whitman portrayed Lincoln by using metaphors such as the captain of the ship of state and made his assassination into a monumental event. Aaron wrote that Whitman treated Lincoln's death as a moment that could unite the American people.^[86] The historian Merrill D. Peterson wrote to a similar effect, noting that Whitman's poetry placed Lincoln's assassination firmly in the American consciousness.^[89] Kaplan considers responding to Lincoln's death to have been Whitman's "crowning challenge".^[90] However, he considers Whitman's poems such as "My Captain" and "Lilacs" to be less bold and emotionally direct than his earlier work.^[91]

Pannapacker concludes that Whitman reached the "heights of fame" through his poetry on Lincoln. He worked to fashion Lincoln as the "redeemer of the promise of American democracy".^[92] The philosopher Martha C. Nussbaum considers Lincoln to be the only individual subject of love in Whitman's poetry.^[93] The Chilean critic Armando Donoso wrote that Lincoln's death allowed Whitman to find significance in his feelings surrounding the Civil War.^[94] Several critics consider Whitman's response to Lincoln's death to memorialize all those who had died in the Civil War.^[95][96] For Whitman, Lincoln's death was the culmination of all the tragedies the Civil War had brought, according to scholar Betsy Erlikka.^[97]

Critics have noted Whitman's departure from his earlier poetry in his Lincoln poems; for instance, in 1932, Floyd Stovall felt that Whitman's "barbaric yawp" had been "silenced" and replaced by a more sentimental side; he noted an undercurrent of melancholy arising from the subject of death.^[98] Ed Folsom argues that, although Whitman may have struggled with his success coming from work uncharacteristic of his other poetry, he decided that acceptance was "preferable to exclusion and rejection".^[99]

Notes

References

General sources

• Aaron, Daniel (1973). The Unwritten War: American Writers and the Civil War. Tuscaloosa, Alabama: University of Alabama Press. ISBN 978-0-394-46583-8.
• Allen, Gay Wilson (1997). A Reader's Guide to Walt Whitman. Syracuse, New York: Syracuse University Press. ISBN 978-0-8156-0488-4.
• Allen, Gay Wilson; Folsom, Ed, eds. (1995). Walt Whitman & the World (PDF). Iowa City, Iowa: University of Iowa Press. ISBN 978-1-58729-004-6. OCLC 44959010.
• Barton, William E. (1965) [1928]. Abraham Lincoln and Walt Whitman. Port Washington, New York: Kennikat Press. OCLC 234090069.
• Bellis, Peter J. (2019). "Reconciliation as Sequel and Supplement". In Sten, Christopher; Hoffman, Tyler (eds.). "This Mighty Convulsion": Whitman and Melville Write the Civil War. Iowa City: University of Iowa Press. pp. 69–82. ISBN 978-1-60938-664-1. OCLC 1089839323.
• Blake, David Haven (2006). Walt Whitman and the Culture of American Celebrity. New Haven, Connecticut: Yale University Press. ISBN 978-0-300-11017-3. JSTOR j.ctt1npt0h.
• Blodgett, Harold W. (1953). The Best of Whitman. New York City: Ronald Press Company. OCLC 938884255.
• Bloom, Harold (2009). Walt Whitman. New York City: Infobase Publishing. ISBN 978-1-4381-1549-8.
• Callow, Philip (1992). From Noon to Starry Night: A Life of Walt Whitman. Chicago: Ivan R. Dee. ISBN 978-1-56663-133-4. OCLC 644050069.
• Coyle, William (1962). The Poet and the President: Whitman's Lincoln Poems. New York City: Odyssey Press. OCLC 2591078.
• Csicsila, Joseph (2004). "Nineteenth-Century Poetry: Whitman, Dickinson, Alice Cary, Phoebe Cary, Larcom, Thaxter, Lanier, Tabb". Canons by Consensus: Critical Trends and American Literature Anthologies. Tuscaloosa, Alabama: University of Alabama Press. pp. 55–85. ISBN 978-0-8173-8178-3. OCLC 320324064.
• Eiselein, Gregory (1998). "'O Captain! My Captain!' (1865)". In LeMaster, J. R.; Kummings, Donald D. (eds.). Walt Whitman: an Encyclopedia. Milton Park, Abingdon: Routledge. ISBN 978-0-8153-1876-7.
• Epstein, Daniel Mark (2004). Lincoln and Whitman: Parallel Lives in Civil War Washington (1st ed.). New York City: Ballantine Books. ISBN 978-0-345-45799-8. OCLC 52980509.
• Erkkila, Betsy (1989). Whitman: The Political Poet. New York City and Oxford: Oxford University Press. ISBN 978-0-19-505438-5. OCLC 17548902.
• Gailey, Amanda (2009). "The Publishing History of Leaves of Grass". In Kummings, Donald D. (ed.). A Companion to Walt Whitman. Hoboken, New Jersey: John Wiley & Sons. pp. 409–438. ISBN 978-1-4051-9551-5.
• Genoways, Ted (2006). "Civil War Poems in 'Drum-Taps' and 'Memories of President Lincoln'". In Kummings, Donald D. (ed.). A Companion to Walt Whitman. Hoboken, New Jersey: John Wiley & Sons. pp. 522–537. ISBN 978-1-4051-2093-7.
• Kaplan, Justin (1980). Walt Whitman: A Life. New York City: Simon & Schuster. ISBN 978-0-06-053511-7. OCLC 51984882.
• Killingsworth, M. Jimmie (2007). The Cambridge Introduction to Walt Whitman. Cambridge, England: Cambridge University Press. ISBN 978-0-511-27529-6. OCLC 153956010.
• Krieg, Joann P. (2009). "Literary Contemporaries". In Kummings, Donald D. (ed.). A Companion to Walt Whitman. Hoboken, New Jersey: John Wiley & Sons. pp. 392–408. ISBN 978-1-4051-9551-5.
• Kummings, Donald D., ed. (2009). A Companion to Walt Whitman. Hoboken, New Jersey: John Wiley & Sons. ISBN 978-1-4051-9551-5.
• Loving, Jerome (1975). Civil War Letters of George Washington Whitman. Durham, North Carolina: Duke University Press. ISBN 978-0-8223-0331-2.
• Loving, Jerome (1999). Walt Whitman: The Song of Himself. Berkeley, California: University of California Press. ISBN 978-0-520-21427-9. OCLC 39313629.
• Matthiessen, F. O. (1968) [1941]. American Renaissance: Art and Expression in the Age of Emerson and Whitman. New York City: Oxford University Press. ISBN 978-0-19-972688-2. OCLC 640086213.
• Miller, James E. (1962). Walt Whitman. New York City: Twayne Publishers. OCLC 875382711.
• Morris, Roy Jr. (2000). The Better Angel: Walt Whitman in the Civil War. Oxford: Oxford University Press. ISBN 978-0-19-512482-8. OCLC 43207497.
• Oliver, Charles M. (2005). Critical Companion to Walt Whitman: A Literary Reference to His Life and Work. New York City: Infobase Publishing. ISBN 978-1-4381-0858-2.
• Pannapacker, William (2004). Revised Lives: Whitman, Religion, and Constructions of Identity in Nineteenth-Century Anglo-American Culture. Milton Park, Abingdon: Routledge. ISBN 978-1-135-92451-5.
• Pannapacker, William (2009). "The City". In Kummings, Donald D. (ed.). A Companion to Walt Whitman. Hoboken, New Jersey: John Wiley & Sons. pp. 42–59. ISBN 978-1-4051-9551-5.
• Parini, Jay (2004). The Oxford Encyclopedia of American Literature. Oxford: Oxford University Press. ISBN 978-0-19-515653-9.
• Peterson, Merrill D. (1994). Lincoln in American Memory. Oxford: Oxford University Press. ISBN 978-0-19-506570-1.
• Price, Kenneth; Folsom, Ed (2005). Re-Scripting Walt Whitman: An Introduction to His Life and Work. Malden, Massachusetts: Blackwell Publishing. ISBN 978-0-470-77493-9.
• Reynolds, David S. (1995). Walt Whitman's America: A Cultural Biography. New York City: Vintage Books. ISBN 978-0-19-517009-2.
• Seery, John Evan, ed. (2011). A Political Companion to Walt Whitman. Lexington, Kentucky: University Press of Kentucky. ISBN 978-0-8131-2655-5. OCLC 707092896.
• Sten, Christopher; Hoffman, Tyler, eds. (2019). "This Mighty Convulsion": Whitman and Melville Write The Civil War. Iowa City, Iowa: University of Iowa Press. pp. 23–32. ISBN 978-1-60938-664-1. OCLC 1089839323.
• Vendler, Helen (1988). The Music of What Happens: Poems, Poets, Critics. Cambridge, Massachusetts: Harvard University Press. ISBN 978-0-674-59152-3.
• Whitman, Walt (1961). Miller, Edwin Haviland (ed.). The Correspondence. Vol. 1 and 2. New York City: New York University Press. OCLC 471569564.
• Williams, Charles Kenneth (2010). On Whitman. Princeton, New Jersey: Princeton University Press. ISBN 978-1-4008-3433-4. OCLC 650307478.

Further reading

• Brown, Clarence A. (Summer 1954). "Walt Whitman and Lincoln". Journal of the Illinois State Historical Society. 47 (2): 176–184. JSTOR 40189372.
• Genoways, Ted (2009). Walt Whitman and the Civil War: America's Poet during the Lost Years of 1860-1862. Berkeley: University of California Press. ISBN 978-0520-25906-5.
• Ignoffo, Matthew F. (1975). What the War Did to Whitman: A Brief Study of the Effects of the Civil War on the Mind of Walt Whitman. New York: Vantage Press. ISBN 0-533-01572-3.
• Matteson, John (2021). A Worse Place Than Hell: How the Civil War Battle of Fredericksburg Changed a Nation. New York City: W. W. Norton and Company. ISBN 978-0-393-24707-7.
• Roper, Robert (2008). Now the Drum of War: Walt Whitman and His Brothers in the Civil War. New York City: Walker & Co. ISBN 978-0-8027-1553-1.