2006-2007

The 2006–2007 school year was a record year for IWU sports, winning conference championships in 10 of the 16 MCC sports, which is a conference record. Both the men's and women's soccer and basketball teams captured MCC championships, the first school to do so. In addition, the men's golf team captured its second straight NCCAA national championship and the women's tennis team won the NCCAA national championship as well (the program's third overall). The men's basketball team qualified for the NAIA national tournament and advanced to the Elite Eight for the first time in program history. However, the story of the year was the record-breaking women's basketball team, who captured the first NAIA national championship in school history by defeating College of the Ozarks in the final. The Wildcats posted a perfect 38–0 record, becoming the first basketball team in NAIA history to go undefeated.^[6]

2007-2008

The Wildcats completed one of its finest athletic seasons to date during the 2007–08 season.^[7] The year started well, including MCC championships in men's (2nd in a row) and women's soccer (10th in a row), women's tennis (17th in a row), men's (3rd in a row) and women's cross country, women's volleyball (2nd in a row), and men's golf. Both the men's and women's soccer teams and the women's volleyball team (6th in a row) secured MCC Tournament championships as well. The men's soccer team posted a 14–3–1 regular season record, the best in program history, reached #6 in the NAIA national rankings (also a record mark), and won the NCCAA Midwest Regional Championship, as well as being ranked #1 in the NCCAA national poll for most of the season. The women's soccer team also won the NCCAA national championship (the program's fourth overall) and finished with a season record of 21–2–1, the best in school history.^[8] IWU was well on its way to securing its seventh straight MCC Commissioners Cup.^[9]

In December, the women's basketball team broke a 24-year-old NAIA record by winning their 48th consecutive game. Despite losing 4 starters from the previous season, they started 2007–2008 18–0, extending their record mark by winning a staggering 56 consecutive games. The historic streak was snapped, however, on January 12, 2008, in a loss to MCC rival Bethel College.^[10] Despite being picked to finish fourth in the preseason MCC coaches poll, the Wildcats exceeded expectations and finished the season in second place in the MCC, behind Bethel College. In the MCC Tournament championship, the Wildcats lost again to Bethel for the third time in the season. However, IWU received an at-large bid to the NAIA National Tournament, where, though favored, they lost in the first round against William Jewell College. The women ended their season with a 28–6 overall record, 3 of the losses coming against Bethel.^[10]

While the women's season started brightly and faded at the end, the men's was the exact opposite. Following a record season in which they were MCC champions and qualified for the Elite Eight for the first time at the NAIA National Tournament, the men were picked to finish first again in the preseason MCC coaches poll. However, they finished a disappointing fourth with a poor 9–7 conference record. More misery ensued with a shocking loss at home to arch-rival Taylor University in the MCC Tournament first round, which ensured that there would be no return trip to the NAIA's. Despite another bad loss at home to MCC rival Spring Arbor University in the NCCAA Regional Final, the Wildcats still qualified for the NCCAA National Tournament in Oakland City, Indiana, as the #1 seed. On March 20, 2008, IWU avenged their earlier loss to Spring Arbor by defeating them 74–61 in the National Championship. The Wildcats finished the season with an overall record of 23–11. The NCCAA national title was the program's first since IWU won it at home in 1995, and the second in program history.^[11]

The men's basketball national championship was IWU's third of a record-setting five NCCAA national titles during the 2007–2008 school year. The women's soccer team won their championship in November, the men's indoor track and field team won in February, the men's outdoor track and field team won in May at IWU, and the women's tennis team also won in May at IWU. In addition, the men's baseball team nearly added a sixth national title, but lost in the NCCAA national championship.^[12] In March, IWU clinched their record seventh straight MCC Commissioners Cup, with an 18-point lead over nearest rival, Bethel College.^[13] Indiana Wesleyan was also awarded the President's Cup of the NCCAA as the best overall athletic program. IWU cruised to the cup with 119 points with a massive lead over runner-up Cedarville University, which had 77.75 points.

2008-2009

Like the previous two school years, 2008-09 also began well for the Wildcats. The men's and women's soccer teams started the season well, both ranked in the top-20 NAIA national polls. The men made history in September by defeating the #1 ranked team in the NAIA, Auburn Montgomery, 6–2 in Alabama. It was the highest ranked team the Wildcats defeated in program history. In October, the men's soccer team won their third straight MCC regular season championship. However, after winning a record ten-straight MCC championships, the women's soccer team failed to clinch the conference title for the first time since 1997 and finished a disappointing third in the MCC.^[14]

In November, the women's cross country team won the MCC championship and the men's cross country team finished second. In the NCCAA national championships, the men finished second and the women finished third. Both teams qualified for the NAIA national championships.^[15] Though finishing a disappointing third in the MCC regular season rankings, the volleyball team won its seventh straight MCC tournament title and advanced to the NAIA national tournament for the first time in program history. In similar fashion, the women's soccer team saved their season by winning the MCC tournament championship and advanced to the NAIA national tournament. However, despite winning the MCC regular season title for the third straight year, the men's soccer team lost to Bethel College (who they shared the conference championship with) in the MCC Tournament championship, missing out on the NAIA national tournament for the third straight year. The loss represented a bitter disappointment for the men's program, as qualifying for the NAIA tournament was a major goal for a talent-laden team including senior standouts Joel Trainer, Christian Davis, Mason Bragg and Ben Chleboun.^[16]

In the NCCAA Midwest Regional semifinal, the men defeated Grace College 6–1. In a rematch of the 2007 NCCAA Midwest Regional Championship, IWU defeated Spring Arbor University 2–0 to claim the 2008 regional title and advance to the NCCAA national championship tournament in Florida for the second consecutive year. The Wildcats were the top seed in the tournament.^[17] In the opening round of the NAIA national championship, the women's soccer team lost 2–0 to defending NAIA national champion Martin Methodist College, after losing top scorer Megan Marshall in a devastating pre-match injury. The volleyball team also lost in the opening round of the NAIA tournament, falling to Dordt College.^[18]

In the NCCAA national championship quarterfinals, the top-ranked men's soccer team defeated 8th-seeded Mid-America Christian University 8–1 to advance to the semifinals.^[19] In the national semifinals, where the Wildcats lost the previous year, IWU defeated 5th-seeded Mid-Continent University 4–3 in a wild match. After taking a 1–0 lead, disaster struck as freshman Ross Tanzer was ejected in the first half, forcing IWU to play a man down for a staggering 70 minutes. However, trailing 3–2 with 10 minutes left to play, senior Joel Trainer and his sophomore brother David scored in dramatic fashion to win the match, clinching the program's first ever birth in a national championship. The IWU victory over MCU avenged a 2005 loss at the same stage in the NCCAA tournament, which was seniors Joel Trainer, Christian Davis, Mason Bragg, and Ben Chleboun's freshman season.^[20] In the national championship match, the Wildcats defeated 3rd-seeded Roberts Wesleyan College 2–0 to clinch the program's first ever national title. After tallying three goals and three assists, Joel Trainer was named NCCAA Tournament Most Valuable Player and Ben Chleboun earned Tournament Most Valuable Defender. Goalkeeper Spencer Lang and sophomore midfielder Mitch Lobdell were also recognized on the All-Tournament Team. The men finished the season with an 18–8 record as MCC regular season champions, NCCAA Midwest Regional Champions, and NCCAA national champions.^[21]

Although the women's basketball team finished a disappointing third in the MCC, the men's basketball team won their second MCC regular season championship in three years, sharing it with Bethel College. With a 25–5 regular season record, the Wildcats secured the second-most wins in program history (after the 2007 season).^[22] Both the men's and women's basketball teams qualified for their respective NAIA national tournaments. The women advanced to the Sweet Sixteen before being knocked out by College of the Ozarks, who they defeated in the 2007 national championship. The Lady Wildcats ended their season with a 24–10 record and qualified for the NAIA national tournament for an impressive seventh consecutive year.^[23] The men advanced to the Elite Eight for the second time in three years before being defeated by tournament host College of the Ozarks, coincidentally the same college that knocked the Lady Wildcats out of the NAIA tournament. Senior standout Antonio Murrell ended his IWU career with a 23-point performance against Ozarks, which made him the fourth-highest scorer in program history. Murrell also holds the IWU record for most career assists. Murrell and junior Zach Coverstone were named NAIA All-Americans after the season. The Wildcats ended their season with a 29–7 record, one win short of the all-time program mark from the 2006–2007 season.^[24]

In April, the men's tennis team won their second-straight MCC championship and the women's team clinched their staggering 18th straight conference title, both with undefeated seasons. While the two tennis titles were the only MCC championships IWU would win during the spring season, they proved to be enough to hold off Bethel College in the MCC Commissioners Cup rankings, clinching IWU's eighth consecutive all sport trophy by a slim 4-point margin.^[25]

Season by season results

Program statistics