Synopsis

The Eleventh Doctor, Amy, and Rory find themselves flickering between two realities, falling asleep at the sound of birdsong in one and waking in the other. In the first reality, Amy and Rory are traveling with the Doctor in the TARDIS, and in the second, five years later, they are happily married in Leadworth and expecting their first child. In the TARDIS, an apparition named the "Dream Lord" appears, and tells them that one world is reality and the other an illusion. He says that they will face a deadly danger in both, and must decide which one is the dream.

In Leadworth, they are chased by the murderous Eknodine, an alien race that have disguised themselves as the elderly of the village. In the other reality, they are trapped in a powerless TARDIS, drifting towards a star that is "burning cold", a collision with which would freeze them to death. The Dream Lord tells them that they must determine which world is the dream and kill themselves in it in order to return to the true reality. However, if they choose wrong, they will be killed in both.

The Dream Lord keeps Amy awake in the TARDIS reality while the Doctor and Rory fall asleep and return to Leadworth. The Dream Lord questions Amy as to which world she would choose: a peaceful married life with Rory or adventure and excitement with the Doctor. Amy returns to Leadworth and joins Rory in defending her house from the Eknodine while the Doctor rescues villagers from the Eknodine in a motor-caravan. He reunites with his companions, but an Eknodine kills Rory. Amy decides that she is willing to risk her own life for the chance of seeing Rory again, and decides--without knowing for certain--that the Leadworth reality is false. Amy and the Doctor crash the motor-caravan into the house. The three wake up on the TARDIS which the Dream Lord reactivates. He admits defeat and departs, after which, to Amy and Rory's surprise, the Doctor directs the TARDIS to self-destruct.

The trio again awaken in the TARDIS. The Doctor realized that both realities were false since the Dream Lord had no power over the real world and was in fact a manifestation of his darker side. The shared dreams were influenced by psychic pollen that had fallen in the TARDIS time rotor and heated up. Amy tells Rory that she does not want to live without him, and the three prepare to embark on another adventure.

Continuity

The Dream Lord describes the Doctor sarcastically as "The Oncoming Storm", a name coined by his archenemies the Daleks, and first mentioned in the Seventh Doctor novel Love and War and subsequently on-screen in "The Parting of the Ways", where it was attributed to the Daleks.^[3] He also says to the Doctor, "You're probably a vegetarian!" in a butcher's shop and calls him "veggie", referring to The Two Doctors (1985), in which the Sixth Doctor announced that he and Peri would eat a vegetarian diet from then on.^[4] The Dream Lord also teases the Doctor's relationship with Elizabeth I. This began in "The Shakespeare Code" where Elizabeth I wished to behead the Doctor^[5] and continued in "The End of Time", which alluded to the possibility the two were married. The marriage between the two was seen three years later in "The Day of the Doctor".^[6]

Writing

"Amy's Choice" was written by Simon Nye, who is known for writing the sitcom Men Behaving Badly.^[8] Nye attended read-throughs of previous episodes to capture the character and "voice" of the Doctor and Amy.^[9] Nye admitted to restraining himself in the change from comedy to science fiction, but said it was "fun" and "hugely liberating". Showrunner Steven Moffat originally gave Nye the premise of the episode for it to fit in the series arc, which was to challenge the Doctor and Amy's relationship.^[7] Nye states that Rory's "death" scene is essentially where Amy realises her feelings for Rory.^[10] Nye wanted to prove that Amy really loved Rory, and he was "not just a cypher boyfriend or fiancé".^[7]

Moffat suggested the idea of the dream split to Nye, who was also influenced by his own dreams and sometimes wondering if they were real. Nye believed that the dream world was consistent with other alternate universes within Doctor Who.^[7] Moffat also instructed Nye to come up with a monster, and Nye chose the elderly people possessed by the Eknodine, reflecting his own fear of old people as a child, but he made clear that he did not intend to make children scared of their grandparents.^[10]

Filming and effects

Skenfrith Castle, where some scenes were filmed^[11]

"Amy's Choice" was the last episode of the fifth series to be filmed, and the editing finished the week it aired.^[12] The read-through for the episode took place on 17 February 2010 in the Upper Boat Studios along with the read-through for episode eleven, marking the final two read-throughs for the series.^[9] The dream sequences taking place in the fictional town of Upper Leadworth were filmed in Skenfrith, Wales.^[9][13]

Karen Gillan had to wear a latex prosthetic stomach bump for the scenes which depicted Amy as pregnant.^[10] She claimed it made her feel more mature and act ridiculously, and cited it as her favourite part of filming the series.^[14] Arthur Darvill wore a wig for the aged Rory, which was trimmed to look "more masculine" and pulled back in a ponytail. The Eknodine were CGI and the scenes were simply filmed with the actors opening their mouths.^[10] The scene in which Rory hits Eknodine-inhabited Mrs Hamil with a plank was filmed first of all with Darvill missing actress Joan Linder, and then again with Linder's stunt double, whom he was allowed to hit. There was only one prop of the plank, and fortunately all the necessary shots were completed before Darvill accidentally broke it.^[10]

Cast notes

Nick Hobbs, who appeared as Mr Nainby in this episode, previously played Aggedor alongside Jon Pertwee's Third Doctor in the stories The Curse of Peladon and The Monster of Peladon. Hobbs has also previously appeared as a lorry driver in The Claws of Axos and operated the Wirrn prop for The Ark in Space.^[15] Audery Ardington, who played Mrs Poggit in the episode, also played the Abbess in The Sarah Jane Adventures episode Eye of the Gorgon.

Critical reception

Gavin Fuller, writing for The Daily Telegraph, was positive about the episode, calling it "probably the strongest all-round script we've had this year, chock full of good lines". He added, "The concept of aliens inhabiting elderly people and turning them psychotic was wittily realised, particularly the bizarre sight of them laying siege to Amy and Rory's cottage with household and gardening implements". He concluded that it "was one of those stories that you would only find in Doctor Who, and shows once again that the series can provide genuine thought-provoking, interesting drama alongside its thrills and spills".^[24]

Matt Wales of IGN rated the episode 8.5 out of 10 and described it as "surreal, fantastical, intriguing, witty, emotional and, at times, genuinely unsettling". Unlike Martin, he said it was "impressive enough on pacing alone" and made a "brisk, refreshing 45-minute episode". However, he criticised the ending for being "glossed over so quickly" and found Upper Leadworth hard to believe.^[25] Keith Phipps, writing on The A.V. Club, graded the episode a B and stated it was "a solid ... entry in what's been a generally terrific season of Doctor Who". He praised Toby Jones' performance as the Dream Lord, saying that "in lesser hands, he might have come off as a copycat version of Star Trek's Q, but Jones makes the part his own". However, he thought its weakness was the pace and "the retirement home-dwelling bad guys, who ultimately seem like a geriatric, and not that frightening, variation on the same old shambling zombies."^[26]

Daniel Martin, reviewing the episode for The Guardian, described it as "at least partially successful". He praised Karen Gillan's performance, saying that she "is capable of more than one-liners and physical comedy – and brings something to your eye, too". However, he thought that the episode lacked ideas and storylines usually found in the show, and criticised the sitcom-style dialogue.^[12] Patrick Mulkern, writing for the Radio Times, was "distinctly underwhelmed", comparing it to "one of the more disappointing episodes of The Sarah Jane Adventures". He "particularly disliked the demonising of elderly people". Upon rewatching, however, although "previous gripes" remained, he did appreciate some the "more subdued" background music from Murray Gold, the script's "tight structure and several amusing lines", and "the realisation that, for the first time, the Doctor is travelling with a couple in love".^[15]

SFX Magazine's Jordan Farley gave the episode 3 and a half out of 5 stars, saying the direction "never quite [struck] the right balance between absurdist humour and sinister nightmare" and the camera was "a little flat" with a strange angle. He was displeased with the discovery that it had all been a hallucination and stated that Rory's death and other instances of horror "never shock in the way you might expect". However, he praised Smith for being "on blindingly good form" while portraying the Doctor's quirkier traits, considered that Gillan and Darvill were "fast becoming the most likeable companion couple in Doctor Who history", and said Jones was "a lot of fun to watch" despite not seeming to be completely the Doctor's dark side.^[27]